iPhone 4S alternatives – Should I get an iPhone 4S?

Want to get a smartphone but not sure you fancy forking out for Apple’s iPhone 4S? We round-up the best alternatives available.
Want a better phone for playing music than the iPhone 4S?
Apple may have the heritage when it comes to making iPods and launching iTunes, but our tests found that the supplied headphones that come with the 4S are disappointing and actually worse than the ones that came with the iPhone 4.
HTC on the other hand has come together with Beats Audio and Dr Dre to release a set of devices that use their not only their headphones, but also software that will tailor how your phone plays music according to which set of headphones is plugged in.
We haven’t yet had the chance to put the Sensation XE – the first device to come with Beats Audio – through our lab tests so we can’t say how the sound quality compares, but if Dre’s involved they must be good, right? You can trust him, he’s a doctor.
Want a better camera than the iPhone 4S?
While the iPhone has been held up as the an example as the best way of doing a lot of things, it’s camera hasn’t always the best. The latest version is certainly a huge improvement and performs exceptionally well but there are still a few features that it doesn’t lead the field on.
The Nokia N8 has an outstanding camera, featuring a resolution of 12Mp and a xenon flash. The inclusion of Carl Zeiss optics means great picture quality and a dedicated camera button makes taking snaps easy.
Yes the Symbian operating system is clunky and has a much lower selection of apps, but if all you’re interested in is getting some good snaps (especially in dark scenes like on a night out) the Nokia N8 isn’t a bad choice.
Want an Android phone that’s better than the iPhone 4S?
OK, without putting the new iPhone to the test in our labs we can’t say for certain that any phone is better than Apple’s latest handset, but Android phones have risen meteorically in the last few years.
The Android Market is fast catching up with Apple’s App Store when it comes to number of apps and without draconian restrictions, it also features the kind of apps that might not get past Apple’s censors.
The Samsung Galaxy S2 has got the highest score of all the Android devices we’ve tested, and was only pipped to the top by the iPhone 4. With a 4.3-inch screen the S2 has more room for web browsing and using apps, plus the 1.2GHz dual-core processor makes swift work of running multiple apps at a time.
An impressive camera and easy-to-use interface complete the package, and while the materials might feel a little plasticky compared with the iPhone, the S2 is super slim and pocket friendly at just 8.49mm thick.
Want a Windows Phone 7 smartphone that’s better than the iPhone 4S?
Maybe iOS and Android aren’t for you and you want a piece of the grown-up Windows Phone operating system. Some great devices have been launched and the new Mango update will add a whole new set of features and bring it up to speed with its older rivals.
A slick, well-designed interface replaces the same old racks of icons, plus you get Windows Office apps and compatibility with xBox Live – giving gamers the chance to gain achievements when they are on the move and play exclusive games.
One the nicest looking devices to sport the new Mango version of the operating system is the Nokia Lumia 800. This not only is made from a spiffy polycarbonate case but also comes with some exclusive software and services. Fancy.
Want a cheaper smartphone than the iPhone 4S?
You want a smartphone with access to all kinds of apps right? One with loads of functions and twiddly bits yeah? But you don’t want to have to donate a kidney in a backstreet doctors to pay for it?
If there’s one single thing Apple’s devices are best known for its not ease of use or design aesthetics – it’s for being very expensive.
The iPhone is no exception, with prices topping £500 for a PAYG handset and it only coming free on contracts north of £35 – and some of those with less minutes and texts than you might find on comparable tariffs with other handsets.
But you don’t need to take out a mortgage to own a smartphone with more and more good devices becoming available for as little as £100.
The Samsung Galaxy Ace certainly has shades of the iPhone 4 in design terms and has the full functionality of an Android smartphone, yet is less than half the price of the iPhone on PAYG and can be picked up free of charge on contracts of just over £10 a month.
Still hankering after Apple’s latest toy? Check out the UK release date, price and deals of the iPhone 4S and see how it the iPhone 4S compares with the iPhone 4.
Post a Comment
Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked





Dave Hook
I have to say how disappointed i am to find Apple have not got the capability to design a new look device in 17months!!! i’m sure i myself could come up with a new look handset in a matter of 3 months or less.I’ve waited for over 6 months to upgrade my handset expecting a new look device,to say i’m disappointed is actually an understatement!!! i now find they want me to upgrade to a device that has been on the market for 17 months!! why on earth would i do that? if i wanted an iphone 4 i would have upgraded 6 months ago!! I now find i either keep what i have “3GS” or wait 6-7 months for the iphone 5 to be released.
I made the mistake of upgrading to the 3GS when that was launched to then be stuck with it for 18 months and after only 6 months they released the iphone 4.
Well i now refuse to wait any longer for any Apple products and i will be changing my iphone for a new Android phone instead!! I will not bow to the idiots that are apple any longer enough is enough.
John W
You don’t have to be “stuck” with anything.
The answer is perfectly simple. Buy an unlocked iPhone from the Apple Store, and then choose whatever tariff gives you the best deal. PAYG or month by month. I’d recommend GiffGaff.
If you sit down and do the sums you’ll find the costs are pretty much the same. Which is obvious really, as the networks subsidise the cost of the phone but want their money back over the life of the contract.
As for your statement “Apple have not got the capability to design a new look device in 17months”. I’m pretty sure it has nothing whatsoever to do with capability. Much more likely that the current design is excellent, very popular and still outsells the competition.
Bradley L
Dave Hook,
How can apple improve on near perfection. Name one android phone that is as good as and iPhone both in terms of what is on the outside and the inside…there is no need to create a new external body because it is already perfect as it is. if you can create a new body in 17 month then do it, but the 4s will still be better than it.
stevie p
Looks aren’t everything, crap battery life unable to change the battery without major work, signal is crap compared to many other smart phones, camera very poor compared to a htc, get a good phone not a smart phone then get an ipod
Paul
Nokia Lumia/N9
a
You’d be stilly to change from an iPhone!
chrisc
you couldn’t have upgraded to the 3GS on the day it came out because I upgraded to the 3GS on the day it came out and had it for a whole year before the iPhone 4 was launched.
additionally you are clearly able to understand that the 3GS was an improvement on the 3G. I fail to see then why you think the iPhone 4S is a phone which has been out for a year?
Fraggy
Want it all ? … Just buy an iPhone.
Paul
Want to look like a generic follower of a bad company? Just buy an iPhone.
Aamprivate
Technically, Android is more of a generic phone. Same operating system, different packaging by different vendors. Windows phone even more so. iPhone (and BB) are the only non-generic options. Good or bad, that is a different question.
Sam
And Nokia is non generic, well at least where I live, no one has one.
Apple-H8ta
Want it all…. to work? don’t buy an iPhone
Mike
Dave Hook says:
I made the mistake of upgrading to the 3GS when that was launched to then be stuck with it for 18 months and after only 6 months they released the iphone 4.
False. The iPhone 4 was released near-as-makes-no-difference 1 year after the 3GS. You upgraded to the 3GS 6 months after it was released. And to be fair, no matter what you buy you end up with the darned thing out of date – to be two models out of date now, nearly 30 months after I bought my 3GS is fair going in my books.
The flipside to this is I don’t know if the iPhone 4S makes enough improvement over the 4 for me to justify paying £500+ for it when the 4 will be on eBay for £300 tops.
John Palmer
Dave Hook. I’m confused. You seem to be arguing both that Apple doesn’t update fast enough, and that they updated too fast for you. You’ve lost me completely. But I look forward to the new iPhone you say you will have ready for us in three months time. Good luck
Aamprivate
@David Hook. iPhone 4s is completely new inside. Even the external antenna has been redesigned to get rid of the “left hand/right hand reception” issue. The previous iPhone 4 piped the best of Android to the top (according the this Which article), so surely the 4s is bound to be the best phone around given that it improves on the previous generation phone. The question is why do need a new iPhone? To show off having the best phone around? In that case I am sure there will be enough small differences to allow you to do that in a subtle way. And frankly, though I don’t use an iPhone anymore, I think the 4/4s look the best. Why change a good external design just for the sake of changing it?
rob
Nice review – and yes i trust dre – he’s a doctor…
Carl White
It never ceases to amaze me how partisan and petty these comments can be! Select the phone you want and get it. If the manufacturer’s innovation cycle is too short for you, go somewhere else for novelty. Most of the smartphones are now so much better than they were when I first bought one. Select, purchase, enjoy. Surely it’s that simple?
Ben1
I tried an iPhone recently for the first time, expecting to be wowed but was distinctly underwhelmed. Fine if you’re an Apple freak but couldn’t see how I could justify paying a premium for not a lot more.
Of course the other thing with iPhone is the lack of choice. With Windows and Android there’s a range of sizes, features and so on. iPhone gives you a choice of 3 apart from colour choices.
Alan Bennett
Any clue as to UK release for Iphone 5. Don’t want to spend on Iphone 4 if just around the corner.
David
I recently followed my son and bought an Apple iphone 4s to replace my blackberry. This is the second Apple product I have bought after and Apple TV. Everyday I seem to understand something else it will do that fascinates me. I am hooked on Apple products
Apple-H8ta
Calling the iPhone “near perfection” is a little ambitious… the iPhone is much, much less than perfect… if it actually worked as a phone it would be adequate at best… my 3G is outperformed at every turn by a Tesco £25 special. I am on O2 payg, and I only get coverage when I am within 50 feet of my wifi at home. The iPhone is merely a ludicrously expensive mp3 player. I would not recommend an Apple iPhone to anyone.
john glaholm
Just heard the blurb about the iPhone 5.. Hope it doesn’t crash out as frequently as my 4S!.. I’m a resolute convert from PC to Mac computers but in my opinion the tablets are disappointing, more rhetoric than reality.. Apple really need to keep on top of technology and not sit on their laurels, they can’t rely upon rubbishing the competition!